Wishing fellow Indians a happy Republic day! Just checked out the new version of Mile Sur Mera Tumhara today: 2 x 8 min videos… huh! And not that exciting! Check out the new ‘Phir Mile Sur Mera Tumhara’: Part 1 | Part 2. Some immediate comments:
- All pure instrumental portions are fantastic: Rahman, Anousha Shankar, tabla, Sivamani, Jazz, …
- Great focus on renewable energy: Solar water heaters and aggregators in the background a couple of times
- S-E-L (Shankar-Eshan-Loy) are great towards the end of their part
- The old-age home (supposedly) & Kashmir parts are very sweet
- Old is Gold: Original music has been tampered too much. Preferred the older Punjabi & Bengali parts (Is Shaan saying send me ‘SMS’?)
- There seems to be no one besides movie stars in this…
- Amitabh Bachchan has been made to sound wierd; he should’ve only been asked to read out the lines
- A bit of over-acting from actors down-under
- No Value Add: The Lux couple, Sonu Nigam, Shahid, Ranbir (in pajamas), Karan Johar
- Salman, Deepika short of clothes
- First 14 mins were great, and then SRK arrives with his silly hand gestures
as if he’s going to jerk of the whole world by closing his fist 
Just compare it to Aamir’s part - Thanks for paying homage to the military at the end
Notable comments from elsewhere:
- why to ruin the good memories with bad bollywood experimentation. It is like comparing SHOLAY with RGV KI AAG
- This “SUR” has become “BESUR” because of bollywood
- Seriously, half of the people in this video didn’t deserve to be there
